Order Now

SHORTCOMING OF LEGAL CASES

Table of Contents
Assignment Part A.................3 Case of Bank Pertanian Malaysia v. Blue Valley Plantation Bhd & ORS...............3
Assignment Part B.................6 Case of Bank Bumiputra Malaysia Bhd. Kuala Trengganu v. Mae Perkayuan Sdn. Bhd. &Anor................6
Assignment Part C...............8 Article ‘Operating with Impunity’...............8
References................10

Assignment Part A

Case of Bank Pertanian Malaysia v. Blue Valley Plantation Bhd & ORS

A per the case study, it has been found that Plaintiff has been granted loan facilities of RM 15,000,000 to the Jute Industries Sdn.Bhd, in order to purchase the 300 acres land. This land has been registered by the plaintiff and the securities that would be provided by the loans are as follows:

  • The loan would be guaranteed by the Mala a/p K.N.K
  • Charge should be made on the land

Thus, the loan has been distributed based on the agreement with the plaintiff. Apart from this, as per the case study, it has been found that in 1999, the plaintiff declared that the jute industries needs to be repayment the loan and the jute industry has also needed to repay of RM22,266,361.68 arrears including their future interest. Further, on 15th September 1999, it has been found that the plaintiff has registered the present Foreclosure Proceeding. The issues of all the papers was systematically served to the accused jute industry who was served as the 1st defendant at the beginning of the present Foreclosure Proceeding. Apart from this, all the interveners have also registered their applications in respect to the position of their said land (Bank Pertanian Malaysia V. Blue Valley Plantation Bhd & Ors High Court Malaya, Kuantan Ramly Ali J, 2002). However, the plaintiff never focus on the interveners application due to which an order has been introduced according to which the plaintiff was considered all present interveners as the defendant

Interveners Interest: As per the case study it has been found that the first interveners had claimed that they had purchased of 37.18 acres of land and this intervener is the actual occupation of that land from October 1993. On the other hand, Teong Pick Ching, Teong Peak Sing and Teong Peck Meng are three intervener in the second interveners namely They even claimed that they have purchased about 12.81 acres of land and the purchase price has been settled completely from 1993. Further, fourth and fifth interveners had been claimed that, they have purchased of 62 acres and 100 acres land and observes an agreement with the 23 interveners and 1st defendants as well as between sale and purchase agreement on october 1996 and 21992 respectively. The interveners had even claimed that their interest on the purchased land would negatively affect if the application of the plaintiff on the Present foreclosure proceeding is permitted.

Matters in dispute and shortcomings

As per the case of Bank Pertanian Malaysia v. Blue Valley Plantation Bhd & ORS, the 1st defendant and the interveners are disputing the application of plaintiff in the Present foreclosure proceeding. As per their affidavits, all the interveners as well as the 1st defendant have claimed that they have able to increase the ‘causes to the contrary’ (Bank Pertanian Malaysia V. Blue Valley Plantation Bhd & Ors High Court Malaya, Kuantan Ramly Ali J, 2002). Apart from this, they have claimed that under the section 256 of National Land Code the court may not be able to provide as decision related to their respective said land. The main area for argument is that, the land charge is invalid due as it was created improperly and the in sustainability of the present foreclosure proceeding. The grounds of this dispute that has been found for the case study have been mentioned below:

  • The interest on the said land that have been claimed by plaintiff is only limited to the 300 acres of land out of 508.875 acres of land. However, the sale order by the plaintiff in preset foreclosure proceeding whole 508.875 acres of the said land has been covered.
  • Apart from this, it has been found from the case study that approximately 208.875 acres of land has not been owned by 1st defendant during the time when plaintiff was created the charge on land. That land proton has been distributed to the interveners and the purchase price has completely paid by the interveners. Thus, the 1st defendant could not able to claim the entire land from the plaintiff.
  • Apart from this, the case study shows that the interveners have been found some difficulties in Form 16A. The reason behind this difficulties or defectiveness in the Form 16A was that in the 4th Column of Schedule in the Form 16 A, the original written figure ‘300/508.875’ were removed and substituted by the word ‘semua’ without having any knowledge and consent of chargor (Amin, 2015).
  • Further, case of Bank Pertanian Malaysia v. Blue Valley Plantation Bhd & ORS has shown that the plantain did not able to maintain and comply with the demand of O. 83 r. 3 of RHC.
  • Moreover, it has been found that plaintiff has been involved in dishonesty. fraud and misinterpretation cases while they were creating charged on the said land.
  • On the other hand, 1st defendant and the interveners had able to accept the ‘causes of the contrary’ for the cause of section.256 of NLC.

Further, as per the study of Aurasu and Abdul Rahman (2018), the former of the blue valley Plantation Sdn Bhd has been facing some charges under the section of 409 Penal code and section 4(1) of Anti money Laundering, Proceeds of Unlawful Activities Act 2001 and Anti terrorism Financing. This case has been investigated by the Malaysian Anti Corruption Commission (MACC) (Noor et al. 2015). They have been following all the registered complaints from the individuals who has been believing that in Blue Valley Plantation, several elements of the appropriate fund is being sold from their property (Rahman, 2016).

Moreover, the former of the Blue Valley Plantation has been accused and has found that he has involved on the money laundering practices and in Public Bank Berhad the firm has deposited of RM216, 666.65 which was owned by Ong Keong Huat legal

Applicable Law

Under section 256 of NLC, the application of the plaintiff for sale order on the purchased land has been made. The section 256 National Land Code or NLC has been used to provide the below mentioned law:

  • Under Section 256 for NLC provides application to the court related to the order for sale
  • This section 256 applied to the land which will be held under:
    • Registry title
    • Qualifies title form related to the registry title
    • Subsidiary title and on the other type of lease related to the land, undivided shares and others
  • In such type of the application, Court would order the sale for the lease or for the land for which the charge has been made unless the charge has satisfied with the existence of the issues related to the contrary.

Apart from this, the case study shows that under the section 256(3) of the of the National Land Code ‘cause of the contrary’ has been introduced under the three case such as

  • While a chargor was being able to file his respective cases under the expectations of the indefeasibility doctrine within the section 340 of the National Land Code
  • When chargore could able to show that the charger did not able to meet the precedent conditions in order to make and applications for the sale order
  • While the chargor could able to show that the permitted orders for the sale can be contrary related to some equity or law

Apart from this, the Federal Court has even introduced some rules which are as follows:

Under the section 256 of the National Land Code, the hearing that would have been taken by the judge is summarizing of the application. The judge would be the responsible person to identify whether chargee has been providing proper and relevant notice that has been introduced in the National Land Code. Apart from this, the judge would also be responsible for ensuring that the entire requirement introduced by the Order 83 of Rules in High Court 1980 has organized in a systematic manner.

Under the section 256 of the National Land Code, the hearing that would have been taken by the judge is summarizing of the application. The judge would be the responsible person to identify whether chargee has been providing proper and relevant notice that has been introduced in the National Land Code. Apart from this, the judge would also be responsible for ensuring that the entire requirement introduced by the Order 83 of Rules in High Court 1980 has organized in a systematic manner.

Under the section 256(3) of the National Land Code, the chargor or the interveners are the responsible person in order to identify the existence of the cause in Contrary based on the balance of the probabilistic. Thus, this would help to the interveners as well as to the chargor to prove that chargee has not made any fault and he has found guilty on the unreasonable conduct.

From the case study, it has also been found that, the section of 340(2) (a) of the National Land Code used to provide registered title or interest that has been kept aside on the misinterpretation ground. As per the case study, it has been found that the plaintiff with the help of their legal practitioners has misinterpreted the situations or the fact that has been documented in the Form 16A. However, the 1st defendants has been executed the documents or the facts that introduced on the Form 16A. This is very unsustainable as well as unreasonable for the legal practitioner to comment that he was responsible for the effect that has been presented during registration.

Thus, from the case of Bank Pertanian Malaysia v. Blue Valley Plantation Bhd & ORS it has been found that the court has satisfied completely by the defendants as well as by the interveners to defeat the application of the plaintiff for order sale under the section of 256(3) of the National Land Code.

Assignment Part B

Case of Bank Bumiputra Malaysia Bhd. Kuala Trengganu v. Mae Perkayuan Sdn. Bhd. & Anor

As per the case study of Bumiputra Malaysia Bhd. Kuala Trengganu v. Mae Perkayuan Sdn. Bhd. & Anor, between first respondent and the appellants there has been occurred some complexities before the respondents has been agreeing to give the bridging finance. On the other hand, the appellants were aware that the respondent would not able to receive income from the targeted project unless the agreements for selling the project have been duly signed by the Bank. The case study shows that during the bridging financial period the appellants did not able to authorize themselves in order to provide the recall letters according to the ground that the first respondents could not get any services from the interest as the first respondent was not accommodate under the pay interest agreement (Bumiputra Malaysia Bhd. Kuala Trengganu v. Mae Perkayuan Sdn. Bhd. & Anor, 1993). Apart from this, it has been found that the typescript words as well as the printed words shows two different agreement. As per the typescript word, it provides the agreement based on the term loan and on the other hand, printed words provide an agreement on the loan that can be repayable based n the demand of the loan (Freedman and Jin, 2017). Contra proferentes rule would help to reject the printed words and agreement has been provided based on the typescript words. Another issues or failure that has been occurred in case of Bumiputra Malaysia Bhd. Kuala Trengganu v. Mae Perkayuan Sdn. Bhd. &Anor was breach contract. This creates negative impact on the respondents while they were treated or agreed upon the term loan on the demand of the loan and recalls the loan in advance (Ramsden and Hamilton, 2017). Apart from this, it has been found from the case study that Dungun project has been faced a loss of profit that has been suffered by the first respondent was probable and the natural result related to the breach agreements with the appellants. This loss of profit has been achieved after the appellants have agreed to give bridging finance to the first respondent. Further, Alor Gajah project has been dependent on the lost profit of the Dungun project which has already been claimed by the Alor Gajah project. In order to mitigate the shortcoming that has been faced by the appellants as well as respondent some legislations such as section 11 Civil Law Act, Section 74 (1) & (2) of Contracts Act 1950, National Land Code 1965 and Rules of the High Court 1980 O.42 and r.12 has been considered (Bumiputra Malaysia Bhd. Kuala Trengganu v. Mae Perkayuan Sdn. Bhd. &Anor, 1993). As per the study of Khan et al. (2017), the National Land Code 1956 has been considered to mitigate the issues related to the land agreement. In Malaysia the national Land Code has been considered by the government of Malaysia in order to consolidate as well as amend the laws for registration of the titled land, land tenure and land and collection of the revenues from the various states in Malaysia. Based on the ideas of Naheem (2017), the National Land Code helps by protecting the land. This protection has been observed under the section 426, 425A, and in section 425 which helps to protect the land from the land related issues.

Further, the case study shows that, the legal practitioner of the Bank has been demanded for repayment of RM4, 322,813.04 from guarantors and from the first respondents in 1985. They would decided to take proper action and if possible they would auctioned their land to the Bank. It has been found that the Bank has registered issues against the respondents at Kuala Terengganu High Court in order to recover the internet, amount of the overdraft and cost and others (Aurasuand and Abdul Rahman, 2018). The judge in the High Court had found that approximately RM 2.1 million has distributed in order to purchase the land that was incorporated in the Alor Gajah Project. The judge dismissed the claim of the plaintiff against the first respondents after analyzing that the Bank had already agreed on the bridging loan finance.

Moreover, it has been found that, Bank never call the chief General Manager in order to provide evidence related to their issues. Based on the study of Balan (2019), two elements related to the bank overdraft are common which are:

  • No fixed period
  • The loan drawdown related to the loan is a way of the issue charge

As per view of Cheong (2019), the term bridging finance is nothing but a process or facilities in the finance which is related to the construction of the lands or houses by the respondent of the land. On the other hand, the bridging finance is the amount that Bank has identified whether the respondents needs to start the operations on the land before the respondents has started to receive amount from the targeted project. All these issues has been considered to be the shortcoming of the Bank that creates several issues between the respondents as well as appellant during land agreement process.

Additionally the study shows that section 74 of the Contract Act 1950, the impact of the breach related to the contract has been mentioned. Moreover, overdraft facilities have been provided by the Bank Bumiputra Malaysia Berhad to the first respondent in order to mitigate their issues related to the appellants and respondents.

Assignment Part C

Article ‘Operating with Impunity’

According to the study of Ajibo (2015), the term ‘Operating with Impunity’ has been considered to be the financial term that helps the business organization to mitigate the Bank related issues. For example, it has been found that several banking sector in European country as well as in US have been facing by several difficulties and issues and they never focused n revoking their banking licenses. Lack of awareness on revoking the banking licence enhances several crimes such as fraud against the customers, public shareholders as well as small shareholders, laundering money, and others. As per the view of Mustafa et al. (2018), devral financials sectors or institution, banks and other organization has failed to reduce the criminal activities, illegal act by their employees, shareholders and customers. Thus, this impunity environment is served as inappropriate for the business organization. Apart from this, the bonus in the banking sectors has been increasing day by day whether the performance of the increased or decreased. Based on the ideas of the Polzin et al. (2016), credit analysis in any financial system plays an important role to analyze the capabilities as well as the ability of the organization in order to make the payment and all the transaction on a systematic manner. Credit analysis is one of the major tools in financial economic system. Effective and efficient credit analysis is necessary for any business organization as well as for the investors in order to analyze the whether the company or the Bank has the capabilities to meet the organizational target. On the other hand, according to the study of Martin et al. (2016), lending management are the process in business organization that supports in meeting the needs of the lenders who are willing to enhance their market stability, reputation, brand image as well as market growth in a effective manner. Thus, the lending management as well as the credit analysis has an effective relation with the Operating Impunity. Operating with impunity helps an business organization to enhance their market growth and stability in a effective manner. On the hand, credit analysis and lending management are also beneficial for the enhancing the business organization in a systematic manner. As per the study of Hollander and Verriest (2016), impunity represents the punishment or escaping of the punishment that has involved by the offended party. As per the international law of the Human Right, the impunity represents the failure that may create several issues related to the human rights violations. Thus, for the analysis it can be stated that, impunity plays a vital role for giving license to the banking sectors as well as help to reshape the business organization in a proper way. Moreover, impunity even helped the banking sectors and the business organization to analyze their credit and enhance their lending management system, in a proper way.

References

Abdullah, F., Chin, O.T., Na’aim, M.S.M. and Dayatie, N.H., 2019. Legislative Enforcement of Contractual Fairness in Malaysian Consumer Contracts. Journal of ASIAN Behavioral Studies, 4(13), pp.51-61.

Ajibo, K.I., 2015. Risk-based regulation: the future of Nigerian banking industry. International Journal of Law and Management, 57(3), pp.201-216.

Amin, N., 2015. Protecting consumers against unfair contract terms in Malaysia: the Consumer Protection (Amendment) Act 2010. Malayan Law Journal, 1, pp.1-11.

Antara, P.M., Musa, R. and Hassan, F., 2016. Bridging Islamic financial literacy and halal literacy: the way forward in halal ecosystem. Procedia Economics and Finance, 37, pp.196-202.

Aurasu, A. and Abdul Rahman, A., 2018. Forfeiture of criminal proceeds under anti-money laundering laws: A comparative analysis between Malaysia and United Kingdom (UK). Journal of Money Laundering Control, 21(1), pp.104-111.

Balan, P., 2019. Damages for Personal Injuries & the Civil Law (Amendment) Act, 1984. Journal of Malaysian and Comparative Law, 16, pp.181-192.

Bank Bumiputra Malaysia BHD.Kuala Trengganuv.Mae perkayuan sdn. Bhd. & Anor. Supreme Court, Kuala Lumpurtun Dato’ seri Abdul Hamid Bin HJ.omar lp, dato’ edgar joseph jr. Scj,dato’ mohd. Eusoff bin chin scj [civil appeal no. 02-219-91]7 April 1993

Bank Pertanian Malaysia V. Blue Valley Plantation Bhd & Ors High Court Malaya, Kuantan Ramly Ali J [originating summons no: 24-133-1999] 2 may 2002

Cheong, M.F., 2019. Banking Secrecy in Malaysia. Journal of Malaysian and Comparative Law, 20, pp.157-182.

Cipovová, E. and Dlasková, G., 2016. Comparison of Different Methods of Credit Risk Management of the Commercial Bank to Accelerate Lending Activities for SME Segment. European Research Studies, 19(4), p.17.

Freedman, S. and Jin, G.Z., 2017. The information value of online social networks: lessons from peer-to-peer lending. International Journal of Industrial Organization, 51, pp.185-222. Hollander, S. and Verriest, A., 2016. Bridging the gap: the design of bank loan contracts and distance. Journal of Financial Economics, 119(2), pp.399-419.

Khan, H.U., Lalitha, V.M. and Omonaiye, J.F., 2017. Employees' perception as internal customers about online services: A case study of banking sector in Nigeria. International Journal of Business Innovation and Research, 13(2), pp.181-202.

Kim, D.W., 2015. The development of the private security industry in South Korea: history, progress, and critical issues, 1950-2014. Journal of Criminological Research, Policy and Practice, 1(3), pp.143-158.

Martin, G.P., Wiseman, R.M. and Gomez-Mejia, L.R., 2016. Bridging finance and behavioral scholarship on agent risk sharing and risk taking. Academy of Management Perspectives, 30(4), pp.349-368.

Mustafa, D., Baita, A.J. and Usman, A.Y., 2018. Impact Analysis of Islamic Finance on Financial Inclusion and Economic Growth in Selected Muslim Countries: Lessons for Nigeria. International Journal of Economics, Management and Accounting, 26(2), pp.393-414.

Naheem, M.A., 2017. Legitimacy of the summer 2017 GCC crisis and Qatar’s AML framework. Journal of Money Laundering Control, 20(4), pp.405-416.

Noor, M.M.M., Suliaman, I., Ahmad, K., Deraman, F., Abdullah, M., Shah, F.A., Yusoff, M.Y.Z.M., Razzak, M.M.A., Meftah, J.T., Ariffin, S. and Kasar, A.K., 2015. The Rights of Khiyar (Option) in the Issue of Consumerism in Malaysia. Middle-East Journal of Scientific Research, 13(2), pp.154-161.

Polzin, F., von Flotow, P. and Klerkx, L., 2016. Addressing barriers to eco-innovation: Exploring the finance mobilisation functions of institutional innovation intermediaries. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 103, pp.34-46.

Rahman, A.A., 2016. Anti-money laundering law: a new legal regime to combat financial crime in Malaysia? Journal of Financial Crime, 23(3), pp.533-541.

Ramsden, M. and Hamilton, T., 2017. UNITING AGAINST IMPUNITY: THE UN GENERAL ASSEMBLY AS A CATALYST FOR ACTION AT THE ICC. International & Comparative Law Quarterly, 66(4), pp.893-921.

Rawlinson, P., 2017. Immunity and impunity: corruption in the state-pharma nexus. International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy, 6(4), pp.86-99.

  3 steps away from success!

  • Complete the order form with details of your assignment.
  • Experienced professional writer will research and write your paper
  • You will receive an original work that meets you needs
Order Now!

What Our Clients Say

Reviews

My Assignments were 100% Plagiarism free

I want to share my experienced with helpmyassignment.com as they gave me guarantee to meet all the requirements of academic writing. The top most quality of the academic writers was that they deliver all my 6 assignments before the deadline without any delay and with Plagiarism reports. They never gave me a chance of any complaint regarding quality as they deliver writing services on time and I have scored very good marks in all 6 assignments.

DOHA: User ID- 14567

Best Customer Support

I am so much glad with the customer support service of helpmyassignment.com. The customer care agents were very quick to respond over the e-mail and telephonic conversation/WhatsApp. They have multichannel support. Thank you to all the people who helped me a lot to deliver the academic projects and put great efforts to complete it in stipulated time frame.

Thalia K Australia User ID: 14787

Appreciate Quality of your Writers

I am a student of MBA in a reputed University in Australia and in my last semester there was a need to complete some of very difficult assignments. The college assigned me the hardest tasks that was financial case study and I was little bit depressed. After that, I heard about helpmyassignment.com and contacted them. They provided me a high quality student level assignments due to which I passed with very good marks. I appreciate your experts for helping me out.

Mercy K, Singapore: User ID-14545

Extremely Happy

I am extreme happy to receive writing services of helpmyassignment.com as there was no issue of plagiarism, content, formatting and it was well referenced as well. The team was very supportive to provide me PhD level assignment with original content and depth research. I really recommend HelpMyAssignment to all the students of Management Colleges.

James P, USA: User ID- 14985

My first doubt was, is my money safe with online assignment providers?

I contacted helpmyassignment.com, and they said," First check the draft free of cost and then pay as per your satisfaction" I accepted and shared my engineering order, they have sent draft next day and I was very confident after checking the draft that I am in right hands. The full assignment was very well drafted and quality was very good. I scored very good Marks.

Ahmed, UK: User ID- 14900

Highly Professional Experts

I am so Glad that I have come across this HelpmyAssignment.com as they provide you with exceptional services. They ensure that you take your work very seriously and provide your assignment before the due date so that you can check it carefully before final submission. I have done many assignments from them and always scored more than 80% in each order. I am happy to be choosing these guys for help as they always allow you to ask for rework free of cost if not happy which is rare.

Maria- Order ID- 6787, Australia

Quality was beyond my Expectation. Thanks Guys

I was skeptical about hiring the online assignment for my Nursing Assignment. Thanks to HelpMyAssignment.com! The experts appointed for my order have done a great work and I have scored 95%. I must say the company is undeniably genuine, secured, and effective from all aspects. It was a well-defined policy. What more can I ask for.? Perfect.! Thanks once again, I recommend all my friends for your services.

Mohamed- Order ID- 6677, UK

On Time Delivery

Thank you so much for your outstanding and A Grade work following all instructions perfectly. 100% better than other service providers. You provide high quality work within the time frame, exactly to the point. I am proud to be associated with you. You are an excellent company with highly experienced staff and high quality of work.

Antonio- Order ID- 6210, USA

Features

Competitive Prices

Competitive Prices

We deliver the best price guarantee to all the students and make sure that the assignment help services for all subjects do not cost much. In addition, we are also ready to deliver some outstanding and exclusive offers.

Written from the Scratch

Written from the Scratch

Each and every assignment that we offer are original, fresh and 100% plagiarism free. Thus, students do not need to feel worried about the fact of whether the content is copied or not.

Safety of the Data

Safety of the Data

We ensure that all the data given or shared with us will remain safe with us because we never disclose them to any of the third party. You don't worry about the fact what will happen to the data.

Proficient Writers

Proficient Writers

We have the best team of PhD writers and they have got the degrees from leading universities from different parts of the world. You will get to have constant assistance from such industry experts who will help you to complete the research work in the best possible manner.

Thorough Analysis

Thorough Analysis

We make sure to conduct out and out in-depth analysis for the paper we work on. All the information and details given in the paper are true to the best of our knowledge. All the data that we use in the papers are backed with authentic sources and include valid details. This would help you to feel your mind with great confidence while submitting the task to the teacher.

Our Working Process In 3 Easy Steps

Request A Quote

Open the assignment order form on our website and fill it correctly. Feel Free to chat with our representative and inquire about your query for free of cost.

Pay For Assignment

Get your Assignment completed at the best prices ! Pay for your assignment through Credit Cards or Paypal at any time you want.

Get Assignment Solution

Our hIghly skilled professional writers ensure you get online assignment help within the deadlines. Makes several revisions for free till 15 days of the delivery.